3 May 2024 - HUGE news - the end of the Reading Recovery programme in New Zealand - its original home!!!

News articles, interviews, research, events and lots more - ready for your comments.
Post Reply
User avatar
Debbie_Hepplewhite
Posts: 2506
Joined: Sat May 23, 2015 4:42 pm

3 May 2024 - HUGE news - the end of the Reading Recovery programme in New Zealand - its original home!!!

Post by Debbie_Hepplewhite »

Outstanding blogger, Professor Pamela Snow, has just announced this latest development via X - the 'end' of Reading Recovery in New Zealand! Pamela writes,
NZ Education Minister Erica Stanford has confirmed the end of #ReadingRecovery in NZ schools. This is history in the making & time now for a true “reading recovery” for NZ children. No child should have to recover from their initial reading instruction
This is truly HUGE news - see the announcement and read people's responses:

https://twitter.com/PamelaSnow2/status/ ... 0374755444

New Zealand was the original home of the Reading Recovery intervention programme created by Marie Clay.
User avatar
Debbie_Hepplewhite
Posts: 2506
Joined: Sat May 23, 2015 4:42 pm

Re: 3 May 2024 - HUGE news - the end of the Reading Recovery programme in New Zealand - its original home!!!

Post by Debbie_Hepplewhite »

This IFERI thread below indicates just some of the concern and ongoing battle for Reading Recovery to be fully understood that it is based on flawed ideas and worrying practices - this has been an international battle indeed:

https://iferi.org/iferi_forum/viewtopic.php?t=861

Reading programmes and materials for teachers and learners may be very well-intended (perhaps always well-intended) but we can see from studying developments over the years (including research findings and leading-edge classroom practice) that there is a danger of programmes and publications becoming so entrenched - whether through methodology or money-making and sheer wide-scale use - that they are virtually impossible to move away from.

If Reading Recovery's day is done, then that is a good thing, about time, and hopefully a sign that the world moves onwards to further understand and embrace the best possible provision for teaching children to read and spell in the complex English spelling system.
User avatar
Debbie_Hepplewhite
Posts: 2506
Joined: Sat May 23, 2015 4:42 pm

Re: 3 May 2024 - HUGE news - the end of the Reading Recovery programme in New Zealand - its original home!!!

Post by Debbie_Hepplewhite »

Direct link including a short video of this important development:

Erica Stanford confirms end of reading recovery programme in schools, doesn't rule out job losses
https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics ... osses.html


This development in New Zealand has been contributed to by the work and research of Professors James Chapman and Bill Tunmer - both gentlemen are on the Founding Committee of the International Foundation for Effective Reading Instruction:

https://iferi.org/team-members/
User avatar
Debbie_Hepplewhite
Posts: 2506
Joined: Sat May 23, 2015 4:42 pm

Re: 3 May 2024 - HUGE news - the end of the Reading Recovery programme in New Zealand - its original home!!!

Post by Debbie_Hepplewhite »

10th May 2024 - Dr Olwyn Johnston kindly let me know about this article below in RNZ where she referenced basing her work on my Phonics International programme:
Using a structured literacy approach to teach reading: What you need to know

by Katie Kenny
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/516 ... -tZDUxyB2t

Olwyn's work and findings are described in this paragraph:
What it looks like

Teachers and researchers repeatedly told RNZ a structured approach isn't a programme, it's a pedagogy.

Deputy principal and special education needs coordinator at Tawa School, Dr Olwyn Johnston, has been using a structured approach - based on Phonics International - and tracking students' progress since 2021.

"We started slowly, by introducing teachers to the science of learning."

She acknowledged "it isn't a magic wand", but as well as improved literacy the school has experienced fewer behavioural problems.

"We talk about shrinking the tail of underachievement. And [at Tawa] we haven't just shrunk the tail, we've docked it," she said. "I couldn't believe our test scores. Yes, some are still struggling. But instead of sitting below the national average, as we were, our tail is now above that. Our whole standard deviation has shifted, incredibly. It's exciting."

She was supportive of the government's mandate but worried about consistency, describing the current approach as "hodge podge".

"We've got to get the right providers to help upskill teachers. And we've got to stop treating this subject as a political football. Our kids are too precious."


About the systematic synthetic phonics programme, Phonics International, see https://phonicsinternational.com

This body of work was first launched in 2007 (by Phonics International Ltd) with an annual licence price for schools and a much less expensive price for parents and tutors. Over time, additional guidance was added and the price was reduced to £20 per year as I realised teachers were turning their attention to 'freebie' phonics resources whether or not these were advisable or better than those of the Phonics International programme. The programme has been utilised in many countries across the world ranging from mainstream provision (for first and additional language contexts), for intervention and for home-educating. The resources are provided online mainly as pdfs which can be printed and/or projected. It is suitable for all ages as required, not just for infants.

In 2011, the education department in England undertook a 'validation' process for 'systematic synthetic phonics' programmes. About seven programmes were validated including Phonics International which was published in the official phonics catalogue under both the mainstream and intervention sections. In a repeat governmental validation process, Phonics International was re-validated in 2021 - and also the pick-up-and-go hard copy programme developed from Phonics International entitled, 'No Nonsense Phonics'.

The Phonics International programme's key picture words for exemplifying the alphabetic code are also used for a wide range of free, overview Alphabetic Code Charts designed for different users and uses, you can see this range here: https://alphabeticcodecharts.com

I always suggest to teachers that they print off the mini Spanish alphabetic code and the English alphabetic code to illustrate the stark differences between the simple, transparent alphabetic code of the Spanish language and the very complex alphabetic code of the English language. This is truly eye-opening for many people, see here:

https://alphabeticcodecharts.com/wp-con ... _Chart.pdf

https://alphabeticcodecharts.com/wp-con ... bleTop.pdf

Additionally, we developed pre-school material which is early phonics for nursery children but based on alphabet letters and the ethos of 'exposure, experience but no expectations' - meaning pressure-free of both adults and children as youngsters will pick up what they are capable of at this tender age. These free resources can be seen here: https://phonicsinternationalpreschool.com

I think it is well worth noting that I have formalised a very specific approach to phonics provision which is 'Two pronged systematic AND incidental phonics teaching and learning' with the ever-present, supportive, overview Alphabetic Code Charts. You can read about this approach via the Phonics International site above.

As I am the phonics consultant for the Floppy's Phonics SSP programme (published by Oxford University Press, 2010), I also ensured that the 'Two pronged' approach underpins the Floppy's Phonics programme too.

To date, no researchers or academics have taken any interest in this two-pronged approach despite me being reasonably well known by some academics and literacy specialists internationally. I also advocate paper-based, content-rich resources for learners to routinely apply themselves at code, word and text level rather than a diet of mini whiteboard activities. To date, no researchers or others have taken any notice of these suggestions. Thankfully, this has not prevented the use of these ideas and resources in many countries and contexts to great effect. Here is just a flavour of feedback:

https://hepplewhite.org/debbie-hepplewh ... racy-blog/


https://phonicsinternational.com/forum/ ... m.php?f=13


If anyone does have an interest in my rationale and ideas, please feel free to email me at debbie@phonicsinternational.com .

And many thanks to Dr Olwyn Johnston who found and investigated the Phonics International programme and has been gracious in making reference to this fact. Olwyn has contributed to the important developments in literacy guidance for New Zealand.
Post Reply