It is very worrying advice - but it includes very commonly-held notions of how to change direction with children who don't appear to be learning phonics very well.
I've added a comment to say as such, but I don't know whether it will be accepted:
https://crossboweducation.wordpress.com ... omment-244
Have you Been Phoniced? (Guest Blog from Beccie Hawes)
We are delighted to be developing a partnership with one of our local Inclusion Advisory teams, based at Rushall Primary School, near Walsall. In this article, head of service Beccie Hawes asks the question…Beccie Hawes
Have you been phoniced? (Pronounced: “phonicked”)
I think I may have invented a new verb! In terms of tenses and in conversation it goes something like this:
“Today I have been phonicing some children in Year One” meaning that today I have taught synthetic phonics to some five and six year olds.
“Yesterday I phoniced some children in Year Two” meaning that yesterday I taught synthetic phonics to some six and seven year olds.
My problem lies in that sometimes we ‘phonic’ children and it doesn’t work and quite often these children have been phoniced for two or three years before someone scratches their head and says “I thinks we need to do something different!” It is at this point that my phone rings and I am asked the million dollar question “What do we do about our phoniced failures?” I have a simple answer…..send them to phonic rehab! What follows is not necessarily what all children will need but part of what should form a rich buffet of approaches for all learners to taste!